When Corey is the only one selected to ride in the special presentation at the horse show, she feels embarrassed, Jasmine feels left out, and May feels caught in the middle.
When Joey Dutton moves away and a new neighbor moves in, May and Jasmine try to find out why lights flicker on and off at night and what is making strange noises in the stable.
Jasmine's first lesson in jumping ends in disaster when her pony stumbles, causing her to take a fall, and it is going to take a great effort on the part of her fellow Pony Tails, May and Corey, to persuade Jasmine to try again.