As Sideways, Jing, Daisy, Shiloh, and Yates prepare for life after high school, their witch coven puts Madeline Kline on trial for stealing and wearing Sideways'--who goes by "they/them" pronouns--soul for a while. However, when they learn of the cruel and unusual punishment Madeline is facing, the Scapegracers decide they have to help her in spite of what she has done.