Quill, Penumbra

When Scootaloo sees Olden Pony, a character from a scary story, she worries that everyone will think she is a scaredy-pony, but before she can sleep she calls on her friends to help solve the mystery of Olden Pony and her rusty horseshoe.

A strange creature is scaring the manes off the ponies in Ponyville, and the Cutie Mark Crusaders are determined to help, with their new friend Lilymoon's hints from her studies to help, if their sleepless nights and strange dreams don't get to them first, especially after Princess Luna starts showing up in their nightmares.

Sweetie Belle, Apple Bloom and Scootaloo tackle a mystery in the dark and spooky region of Livewood.

The Cutie Mark Crusaders are excited about celebrating Zipporwhill's birthday, then, during the party, a timberwolf appears, and when it seems to be more interested in candy than the ponies, their new friend, Lilymoon, suspects they are dealing with a werepony, half pony and half timberworlf, and the Cutie Mark Crusaders are on the case.

A young Unicorn named Lilymoon arrives at Ponyville Schoolhouse, and she has no interest in making friends, then strange things start happening around the schoolhouse, and she is the prime suspect, the Cutie Mark Crusaders need to find out what Lilymoon wants before it's too late.