Jeff, Mara, Kelly, and Brian call themselves the Goofballs, private eyes who solve mysteries together with their secret weapon, Sparky the Goofdog. This time around they investigate a ghost haunting at the abandoned Hyde House.
When wealthy Randall Crandall asks the Goofballs to protect his collection from a thief, the detectives agree and attend his superhero party in disguise to find the culprit.
While rehearsing for their school's upcoming talent show, Jeff, Mara, Brian and Kelly learn of strange goings-on during rehearsals. Determined to help, the four friends try to solve the mystery before the show is canceled.