As Rumble the dragon and Shelby Spider watch, Harry Hippo must find a way to keep the boat to Rumble's Cave Hotel afloat when Eli Elephant tries to board and sets the vessel off balance.
Felicio's father does not believe in the tooth fairy, the Sandman, or Santa Claus, but when he loses a tooth and odd things start to happen, including the Tooth Fairy arriving, he slowly begins to change his mind.