Andi Talbot is thrilled to receive horseback-riding lessons as a gift from her father, but when a pony named Sunshine disappears, she is forced to put her lessons on hold. Andi and her friends use their pet-finding skills to search for Sunshine.
When Buddy is frightend by a storm, he races out of his new home in his new neigborhood and can't find his way back. Andi and her new friends search for Buddy and their compassion for all animals inspires the Pet Finders Club.
The combined efforts of Andi and her friends fuel the search for an injured Labrador's owner, and their compassion for all animals inspires the Pet Finders Club to keep every pet in Orchard Park safe.