Colette's life is near-perfect, if boring, so when her ex-best friend, Sadie, asks her to come on vacation to the Greek Islands for a family wedding, Colette agrees but is surprised to learn Sadie's true reason for the invitation.
Playing the "bad girl" at school to get back at her feuding parents, sixteen-year-old Evelyn gets into drugs and sex with a bad boy and becomes pregnant. Horrified that this could happen to her, she wonders how she will cope with a baby and still be valedictorian and realize her Ivy League dreams. When the baby's father wants nothing more to do with her or the child, Evelyn faces some difficult decisions.