Felicio's father does not believe in the tooth fairy, the Sandman, or Santa Claus, but when he loses a tooth and odd things start to happen, including the Tooth Fairy arriving, he slowly begins to change his mind.
A houseful of relatives turns "Mrs. C." and Santa's Christmas into a string of surprises, from the arrival of a pet polar bear to Cousin James B.'s flaming plum pudding.
Armed with the facts, young Alfie sets out to prove to the world that Santa Claus does not exist, but no one pays attention, especially his sister Noelle, whose only request of the man in red is a nicer big brother.
As a family lives out the famous poem by Clement Moore, a young boy is unable to sleep, and, in his excitement, performs several deeds bound to place him on the naughty list, and one that just might save him.
After taking a walk on Christmas Eve while their freshly baked gingerbread cools, Papa, Mama, and Baby Bear arrive home to encounter another "trespasser," who does not have golden hair but wears a red suit and leaves presents.
On Christmas Eve, Sam and the members of his Wild West Show help a train full of people, robbed by outlaws who have just captured a very special holiday traveler in red.
