Honey Perkins is a former classmate who is so obsessed with Becka Norwood that she not only transforms herself to look like her, she also stages a series of accidents to get rid of all Becka's friends.
Nicole and her best friend Lucy decide to switch bodies at the Changing Wall in the woods, but when Lucy's parents are murdered, Nicole finds herself trapped as Lucy--and the primary suspect.
Jade and Deena receive threatening phone calls but they aren't sure if the caller is serious or is just playing a sick joke. Then they realize that someone is watching them and is close enough to know their every move.
Corky has returned to the Shadyside cheerleading squad following the nightmare of Bobbi's death, but the murders have begun again, and she wonders if the evil spirit from the Fear Street cemetery has returned.
Bryan wants the Cataluna more than anything else, and he would even steal or kill for it. But inside this sleek white car lives an ancient evil that wants Bryan.
Johanna, having finally gotten her wish to be part of Dennis Arthur's rich, popular crowd, has to decide how much she wants to keep Dennis as her boyfriend when he dares her to kill their teacher.