An itinerant shoemaker in colonial New England makes a pair of shoes for a beautiful young woman, although he fears the red heels are a sign that she is a witch.
On her first night on the job at Miss Marvel's Witch Agency, Glenda's inability to keep her spells straight involves her in a bank robbery and a mad chase to catch the crooks.
Abby is the best speller in the class until a new witch shows up at school and the two of them compete in a spelling bee to see who will win a new broomstick.
Nicky and his mother's efforts to turn an old New England house into a tearoom are hampered by the old witch who haunts the place, until they learn how well she cooks.