While all of Strattenburg anxiously awaits the new trial of infamous murder suspect Pete Duffy, problems arise for their own kid lawyer. There's been a robbery, and Theo is the accused.
Mimi fascinates Christina and Grant as she recounts the mystery of the lost colony of Roanoke Island, where a group of settlers vanished, with few clues as to what happened to them.
Jess Mastriani has a penchant for getting in trouble, but her problems multiply when she is struck by lightning and wakes up the next morning with a supernatural talent for finding lost or missing children.
The reader is asked to travel to Thailand to investigate the disappearance of an American businessman, and can choose between alternative adventures, each leading to nineteen possible endings.