In the prestigious Saint Lawrence Academy, the most elite clique is MASCARA, which stands for Mara, Asher, Sue, Carmen, Amanda, Rachel, and Adrianna. Each new year, leaving seniors are replaced by incoming freshmen, but only if those freshmen have names that start with the letters in "MASCARA." Incoming freshman Marjorie Carr, who more often goes by Jorie, is given a "bid" to get into the clique--signature blue mascara--but passing the pledging rituals may force Jorie to give up her best friend, Abby, who was the one who told Jorie about MASCARA in the first place.